The college football world was rocked today by a stunning decision from one of the most highly touted high school prospects in recent history. Five-star recruit and top-rated quarterback, Jalen Carter, shocked fans, coaches, and analysts alike by decommitting from Texas Christian University (TCU) and spurning massive NIL deals to pledge his commitment to the LSU Tigers over powerhouse programs Notre Dame and Georgia.
A Recruiting Saga Unlike Any Other
Carter, a 6-foot-4, 215-pound dual-threat quarterback out of St. John Bosco High School in California, has been one of the most sought-after players in the 2025 recruiting class. Ranked as the No. 1 quarterback and a top-three overall player by multiple recruiting services, his college decision has been the subject of speculation for months.
Initially committing to TCU in what was seen as a major win for the Horned Frogs, Carter’s recruitment took a dramatic turn when rumors began swirling about massive Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) deals from powerhouse programs looking to flip his commitment. Reports indicated that Carter was offered up to $6.7 million in NIL incentives from various collectives associated with competing schools.
Yet, in a move that has defied expectations, Carter turned down those lucrative offers, withdrew his pledge to TCU, and chose LSU instead, citing a combination of football development, long-term stability, and personal aspirations.
Why LSU?
In an exclusive interview following his commitment, Carter explained his decision:
“I respect what TCU has built, and I appreciate everything Coach Sonny Dykes and his staff have done for me throughout this process. But after deep reflection and conversations with my family, I realized that LSU was the best place for me to develop as a player and person. The culture, the fan base, and the vision Coach Brian Kelly has for the program really stood out.”
LSU’s track record with quarterbacks in recent years certainly played a role in Carter’s decision. The Tigers have produced Heisman winners like Joe Burrow, and under Kelly’s leadership, they continue to build an offense that caters to elite-level quarterbacks.
Additionally, LSU’s recent success in recruiting top talent at offensive skill positions ensures that Carter will be surrounded by an elite supporting cast. With a strong offensive line and one of the best receiving corps in the country, the Tigers presented an enticing opportunity for the young star.
The NIL Factor: Why Turn Down $6.7 Million?
In an era where NIL money has become a dominant force in college football recruiting, Carter’s decision to turn down a $6.7 million offer raises eyebrows. When asked about it, he responded candidly:
“I’m not chasing the biggest check. I want to go somewhere I can develop into an NFL quarterback, win championships, and leave a legacy. NIL money is great, but I trust that if I perform on the field, the financial side will take care of itself.”
This statement is refreshing in today’s landscape, where NIL deals are increasingly swaying top prospects. Carter’s belief in himself and his long-term vision speaks volumes about his character and confidence.
Reaction from the College Football World
The ripple effects of Carter’s decision have been felt across the college football landscape.
TCU’s Response
TCU, which had been riding a wave of recruiting momentum following their 2022 College Football Playoff run, was blindsided by the news. Coach Sonny Dykes released a statement wishing Carter well while emphasizing that the Horned Frogs remain committed to their long-term vision.
“We respect Jalen’s decision and wish him nothing but success at LSU. Our program continues to build towards the future with the outstanding talent we have on our roster and the young men who believe in what we’re creating here in Fort Worth.”
Notre Dame and Georgia’s Perspective
Both Notre Dame and Georgia were considered strong contenders for Carter, and the news of his commitment to LSU came as a major disappointment. Georgia, which has dominated recruiting in recent years under Kirby Smart, was especially aggressive in their pursuit of Carter, hoping to add him to their growing legacy of elite quarterbacks.
Notre Dame, under Coach Marcus Freeman, had also made a strong push, selling Carter on the opportunity to be the face of a historic program that has lacked an elite quarterback in recent years.
LSU Fans Rejoice
For LSU fans, Carter’s commitment represents a massive recruiting win. Social media exploded with excitement, with many drawing comparisons to Joe Burrow’s arrival in Baton Rouge. Some fans even started referring to Carter as the future “Bayou Burrow.”
LSU’s 2025 recruiting class is already shaping up to be one of the best in the country, and adding Carter only solidifies their standing among the elite.
What’s Next for Carter?
Now that his recruitment is settled, Carter will shift his focus to finishing his senior year strong and preparing for the transition to college football. With expectations sky-high, all eyes will be on him when he arrives in Baton Rouge.
LSU fans will be eagerly awaiting to see if Carter can live up to the hype and help lead the Tigers back to the College Football Playoff and beyond.
Final Thoughts
Jalen Carter’s decision to decommit from TCU and choose LSU over powerhouse programs like Georgia and Notre Dame will go down as one of the most fascinating recruiting stories of the NIL era. His willingness to forgo massive financial incentives in favor of long-term success speaks volumes about his mindset and determination.
In the ever-changing landscape of college football, Carter’s choice proves that, for some players, legacy and development still matter more than money. Now, the challenge lies ahead—to live up to the expectations and cement his name among the greats at LSU.