Choosing a college softball program is one of the most significant decisions a young athlete can make. For Peyton Hardenburger, a highly touted recruit with a bright future, the decision came down to two powerhouse programs: the Oklahoma Sooners and the Tennessee Lady Vols. Both schools boast rich traditions, elite coaching staffs, and a history of producing championship-caliber teams. Yet, when it was time to make her commitment, Hardenburger chose the Sooners. While many factors likely played into her decision, two key reasons stood out above the rest: Oklahoma’s unparalleled culture of winning and the program’s ability to develop players into complete athletes, both on and off the field.
1. A Culture of Winning and Championship Pedigree
When it comes to dominance in college softball, few programs can match what Oklahoma has built under head coach Patty Gasso. The Sooners have set the standard for excellence, consistently competing for national titles and producing some of the game’s most iconic players. For a competitor like Hardenburger, joining a program that expects to win—and does so relentlessly—was an opportunity too good to pass up.
Oklahoma’s recent success is nothing short of historic. The Sooners have claimed multiple Women’s College World Series (WCWS) championships in the past decade, including back-to-back titles in 2022 and 2023. Their ability to reload rather than rebuild speaks to the program’s depth and the coaching staff’s knack for developing talent. Tennessee, while a strong program with its own proud history, has not reached the same level of sustained dominance in recent years. The Lady Vols are undoubtedly competitive, but Oklahoma’s track record of winning at the highest level—often in dominant fashion—sets them apart.
Beyond the trophies and accolades, what makes Oklahoma’s culture unique is the mindset instilled in every player. The Sooners play with a confidence that comes from knowing they’ve been there before. They thrive under pressure, and their ability to perform in clutch moments is a testament to the program’s preparation and mental toughness. For Hardenburger, who wants to compete for championships every single year, Oklahoma’s winning culture was a major draw.
2. Player Development and the Complete Athlete Experience
While winning is a priority, Oklahoma’s ability to develop players into well-rounded athletes was another deciding factor for Hardenburger. Under Patty Gasso’s leadership, the Sooners don’t just recruit talent—they refine it, polish it, and prepare players for success beyond college. Whether it’s improving offensive mechanics, defensive versatility, or mental resilience, Oklahoma has a proven system for helping athletes reach their full potential.
One of the most appealing aspects of the Sooners’ program is their offensive philosophy. Oklahoma hitters are known for their discipline, power, and ability to perform in high-pressure situations. The coaching staff emphasizes a balanced approach, ensuring players can hit for average, drive in runs, and come through in clutch moments. For a player like Hardenburger, who takes pride in her offensive game, the opportunity to learn from some of the best hitting minds in the sport was a major factor.
Defensively, Oklahoma prides itself on versatility. The Sooners routinely field players who can excel at multiple positions, making them one of the most adaptable teams in the country. This flexibility not only strengthens the team but also prepares players for the next level, where versatility is often a key to longevity. Tennessee, while strong defensively, doesn’t have the same reputation for positionless play that Oklahoma does.
Off the field, Oklahoma’s commitment to its athletes’ personal growth was another selling point. The program emphasizes leadership, accountability, and community involvement, ensuring players leave as better people, not just better softball players. The family-like atmosphere within the team is something recruits often mention, and it’s clear that the bonds formed in Norman last well beyond graduation.
