Shohei Ohtani, the Los Angeles Dodgers’ two-way superstar, is growing increasingly impatient with his recovery timeline. After undergoing elbow surgery in September 2023, Ohtani was expected to focus solely on hitting in 2024 while rehabbing his arm for a potential return to the mound in 2025. However, recent reports suggest that the reigning American League MVP is eager to accelerate his timeline and resume pitching sooner than anticipated.
Ohtani’s competitive nature is no secret. Since debuting in Major League Baseball (MLB) in 2018, he has consistently defied expectations, proving that a player can excel as both an elite hitter and pitcher in the modern era. His unprecedented two-way success earned him two MVP awards (2021, 2023) and made him the face of baseball. But now, as he watches from the dugout while his teammates take the mound, his frustration is becoming evident.
### **The Road to Recovery**
Ohtani’s latest elbow surgery, his second major procedure since 2018, was performed by Dr. Neal ElAttrache to repair a torn ulnar collateral ligament (UCL). Unlike his previous Tommy John surgery, this operation was a hybrid repair—part internal brace, part traditional ligament reconstruction—with the hope of a faster recovery. The initial prognosis suggested a return to pitching in 2025, but Ohtani’s rapid healing progress has raised speculation that he could be back on the mound before the end of this season.
The Dodgers, cautious about their $700 million investment, have been adamant about not rushing him. However, Ohtani’s recent comments indicate he is pushing for an earlier return. In a post-game interview last week, he admitted, “I feel strong. My arm is responding well, and I want to contribute in every way possible. Waiting until next year is tough.”
### **Ohtani’s Competitive Fire**
What drives Ohtani’s impatience? The answer lies in his relentless drive to compete. Unlike many players who might embrace a year of designated hitting (DH) duties to ease their workload, Ohtani thrives on the challenge of dual roles. Pitching isn’t just a secondary skill for him—it’s a fundamental part of his identity as a baseball player.
Former teammates and coaches have often remarked on his work ethic. “He’s not the type to sit around,” said a former Angels staffer. “Even on his off days, he’s working on something—whether it’s refining his swing, studying pitchers, or doing arm care. Sitting out from pitching is eating at him.”
This mindset explains why Ohtani has already begun light throwing sessions, well ahead of schedule. While the Dodgers’ medical staff monitors his progress closely, insiders suggest he is lobbying for a late-season return if the team is in playoff contention.
### **The Dodgers’ Dilemma**
Los Angeles faces a tricky balancing act. On one hand, Ohtani is their franchise player, and his long-term health is paramount. Another elbow setback could jeopardize the remainder of his 10-year contract. On the other hand, his presence on the mound could be a game-changer in October.
The Dodgers’ pitching staff, while deep, has dealt with injuries (Walker Buehler’s delayed return, Clayton Kershaw’s shoulder issues) and inconsistency. Adding Ohtani to the rotation—even in a limited capacity—could provide a significant boost. However, manager Dave Roberts has remained noncommittal, stating, “We’re following the doctors’ recommendations. Shohei’s health comes first.”
### **Historical Precedents and Risks**
Ohtani’s situation isn’t entirely unprecedented. Other pitchers, like Stephen Strasburg and Jacob deGrom, have attempted comebacks from multiple arm surgeries with mixed results. The difference is that Ohtani isn’t just a pitcher—he’s also one of the best hitters in baseball. The Dodgers must weigh whether the risk of re-injury outweighs the potential reward of having him pitch in 2024.
Some analysts argue that Ohtani’s competitive nature could work against him. “He’s so used to pushing limits that he might not recognize when to dial it back,” said one MLB scout. “The Dodgers have to protect him from himself.”
### **Fan and Media Pressure**
The external pressure is also mounting. Dodgers fans, eager to see Ohtani’s full two-way brilliance, have taken to social media, urging the team to let him pitch sooner. Meanwhile, baseball purists and media members debate whether the Dodgers are being overly cautious or rightfully prudent.
Ohtani himself has remained diplomatic but firm. “I trust the team’s plan,” he said, “but of course, I want to be out there doing everything I can to help us win.”
### **What’s Next?**
As the season progresses, all eyes will be on Ohtani’s throwing program. If he continues to progress without setbacks, the Dodgers may face increasing pressure to let him test his arm in live game situations. A best-case scenario could see him making a few relief appearances in September before potentially joining the playoff rotation.
However, if the medical staff detects any red flags, they will likely shut down any pitching plans immediately. The last thing the Dodgers want is another long-term injury to their generational talent.
Shohei Ohtani’s desire to return to the mound is a testament to his unparalleled passion for the game. Few athletes in history have possessed his combination of skills, and even fewer have his level of determination. Yet, the Dodgers must navigate this situation carefully. Rushing him back could have catastrophic consequences, but holding him back too long might frustrate a player who lives to compete.
For now, Ohtani waits—but his patience is wearing thin. Whether he takes the mound in 2024 or 2025, one thing is certain: baseball is better when Shohei Ohtani is doing what he does best—dominating as both a hitter and a pitcher. The only question is how soon we’ll see it again.
