The Big One: Which Former Buckeye Should Be Ohio State’s Next Coordinator?

Ohio State football has a rich tradition of producing elite players and top-tier coaching talent. From legendary coaches like Woody Hayes to former players who have transitioned into coaching roles, the Buckeyes have always maintained a strong football culture. With the ever-evolving landscape of college football, there is always speculation about who could return to Columbus to help lead the team. One of the most exciting discussions among Ohio State fans is which former Buckeye should step into a coordinator role at their alma mater.

The Importance of a Strong Coordinator

In modern college football, coordinators play an essential role in shaping a team’s success. Whether it’s the offensive coordinator designing innovative schemes or the defensive coordinator building a dominant unit, these positions can make or break a team’s chances at contending for a national championship.

Ohio State has historically been one of the most dominant programs in the country, but recent struggles against top-tier opponents, particularly Michigan, have fans and analysts questioning whether changes should be made within the coaching staff. Many believe that bringing in a former Buckeye with deep ties to the program and a strong understanding of Ohio State’s culture could be the solution.

With that in mind, let’s take a look at some of the best former Buckeyes who could be ideal candidates for a coordinator position at Ohio State.

1. Mike Vrabel – Defensive Coordinator

Why He’s the Right Choice:

Mike Vrabel is one of the most respected names in football, both as a player and a coach. A dominant defensive lineman for Ohio State in the 1990s, Vrabel won multiple Big Ten Defensive Lineman of the Year awards and went on to have a highly successful NFL career with the New England Patriots, winning three Super Bowls.

After his playing career, Vrabel quickly made a name for himself in coaching. He served as Ohio State’s defensive line coach under Urban Meyer before moving on to the NFL, where he has since become a successful head coach with the Tennessee Titans.

If Ohio State is looking for a tough, disciplined, and aggressive defensive coordinator, Vrabel would be an ideal fit. His knowledge of the game, leadership skills, and ability to develop players would bring a new level of intensity to the Buckeyes’ defense.

Challenges:

The biggest obstacle to bringing Vrabel back to Columbus is his current position as the Titans’ head coach. Leaving the NFL for a coordinator position in college would be a step down in prestige and salary. However, if circumstances change and Vrabel becomes available, he would be a dream hire for the Buckeyes.

2. Brian Hartline – Offensive Coordinator

Why He’s the Right Choice:

Brian Hartline has already proven to be one of the best assistant coaches in college football. A former Ohio State wide receiver, Hartline played in the NFL before returning to Columbus as a coach. Since taking over as wide receivers coach, he has developed an elite unit year after year, producing NFL stars such as Chris Olave, Garrett Wilson, and Jaxon Smith-Njigba.

Given his recruiting success and deep understanding of Ohio State’s offensive philosophy, Hartline is a natural candidate for a promotion to offensive coordinator. His ability to connect with players and create explosive offenses would make him an excellent leader for Ohio State’s attack.

Challenges:

While Hartline is an elite recruiter and position coach, the transition to offensive coordinator comes with additional responsibilities, including play-calling and game-planning. There is always a risk when promoting a position coach to coordinator, but Hartline’s trajectory suggests he has the potential to thrive in the role.

3. James Laurinaitis – Defensive Coordinator

Why He’s the Right Choice:

James Laurinaitis is one of the most beloved Buckeyes in recent history. A three-time consensus All-American and Butkus Award winner, Laurinaitis was a leader on the field during his time at Ohio State and later enjoyed a successful NFL career.

Since retiring, Laurinaitis has transitioned into coaching, working as a defensive assistant under Marcus Freeman at Notre Dame before returning to Ohio State in 2023. Given his football intelligence and leadership skills, he is a natural candidate to rise through the coaching ranks.

Laurinaitis has a deep passion for Ohio State, and his presence could help restore the Buckeyes’ defensive dominance. His experience as a linebacker would be particularly valuable in developing the heart of the defense.

Challenges:

Laurinaitis is still in the early stages of his coaching career, so promoting him directly to defensive coordinator might be premature. However, with the right mentorship and experience, he could be a future star in the coaching world.

4. Chris Spielman – Defensive Coordinator

Why He’s the Right Choice:

Chris Spielman is a Buckeye legend. A dominant linebacker in the 1980s, Spielman became an Ohio State icon before enjoying a successful NFL career. Since retiring, he has remained involved in football through broadcasting and front-office roles.

Spielman’s football mind and leadership qualities are undeniable. His presence on the coaching staff would bring instant credibility, and he could help instill a tougher mentality on the defensive side of the ball.

Challenges:

While Spielman has vast football knowledge, he lacks direct coaching experience at the college level. Making the jump from the front office and media world to a coordinator role would be a significant adjustment.

5. Kenny Guiton – Offensive Coordinator

Why He’s the Right Choice:

Kenny Guiton is a fan favorite at Ohio State, known for his leadership and ability to step up in clutch moments. Since his playing days, Guiton has built a solid coaching resume, working as a wide receivers coach and passing game coordinator at multiple programs.

Guiton’s offensive mind and familiarity with Ohio State’s system make him an intriguing option. His ability to develop quarterbacks and design creative passing attacks could help modernize Ohio State’s offense.

Challenges:

Guiton is still gaining experience as a coach, and while he has shown promise, he has yet to hold a full offensive coordinator role at a major program. He would likely need more experience before being considered for the Buckeyes’ OC position.

Conclusion: Who Is the Best Fit?

If Ohio State is looking for a proven, elite defensive coordinator, Mike Vrabel would be the ultimate hire, though his availability remains uncertain. If he is not an option, James Laurinaitis could be the next best long-term solution, as he continues to gain coaching experience.

On offense, Brian Hartline is the most logical choice given his current trajectory. His ability to recruit and develop talent is already among the best in college football, and a promotion to offensive coordinator could be the natural next step.

Ultimately, Ohio State has a wealth of talented former players who could make excellent coaches. Whether it’s Vrabel, Hartline, Laurinaitis, Spielman, or Guiton, bringing a former Buckeye into a leadership role could help the program get back to the top of college football.