Vanderbilt Commodores Hoping History Repeats Itself Against Volunteers

The Vanderbilt Commodores football team finds itself in a familiar position as they gear up to face their in-state rivals, the Tennessee Volunteers. With decades of heated matchups behind them, the Commodores are hoping that history, particularly the favorable chapters, will repeat itself when they meet again on the gridiron.

The rivalry, affectionately known as the “Battle for Tennessee,” carries deep historical significance for both programs. Though Tennessee has largely dominated the series, Vanderbilt has had its moments of triumph, many of which have come under unique and inspiring circumstances. As the two teams prepare for this year’s clash, the Commodores aim to channel the spirit and strategy of those historic victories.

A Rivalry Steeped in Tradition

The Vanderbilt-Tennessee rivalry dates back to 1892, making it one of the oldest rivalries in college football. Over the years, the Volunteers have established themselves as a powerhouse, often overshadowing Vanderbilt. However, the Commodores have demonstrated resilience and tenacity, occasionally pulling off stunning upsets that reverberate across the Southeastern Conference (SEC).

For Vanderbilt, the rivalry represents more than just a football game. It’s a chance to prove that despite being historically viewed as underdogs, they can compete with and defeat their more celebrated counterparts. The Commodores’ victories in this rivalry, while fewer, have often been defined by strategic brilliance and an indomitable spirit—qualities they hope to replicate this season.

Learning from Past Successes

To understand Vanderbilt’s hopes for the upcoming game, it’s worth revisiting some of their most memorable wins against Tennessee. One such instance came in 2016 when the Commodores upset the Volunteers 45-34 in Nashville. Quarterback Kyle Shurmur led the charge with 416 passing yards and two touchdowns, while the defense made crucial stops to seal the victory. That game not only secured bowl eligibility for Vanderbilt but also showcased their ability to rise to the occasion against a formidable rival.

Another iconic moment occurred in 2012, when Vanderbilt routed Tennessee 41-18. That victory marked a turning point in the rivalry, as it was the first time since 1982 that Vanderbilt had defeated Tennessee by such a wide margin. Led by head coach James Franklin, the Commodores displayed a level of confidence and execution that set a new standard for their program.

These victories underscore a common theme: when Vanderbilt embraces a fearless mindset and executes a well-rounded game plan, they are capable of toppling the Volunteers. The current team’s challenge lies in drawing inspiration from these moments while crafting their own path to victory.

The 2023 Season: A Test of Growth

The 2023 season has been a mixed bag for Vanderbilt. Head coach Clark Lea, now in his third year at the helm, has emphasized building a sustainable program rooted in discipline and development. While progress has been evident in certain areas, consistency remains a challenge.

Offensively, the Commodores have shown flashes of brilliance, particularly in their passing game. Quarterback AJ Swann has demonstrated poise under pressure, connecting with playmakers like Will Sheppard and Jayden McGowan. However, turnovers and missed opportunities have often hindered their ability to close out games.

Defensively, Vanderbilt has struggled to find its footing against high-powered offenses. The secondary has been a point of concern, frequently giving up big plays. To stand a chance against Tennessee, the Commodores will need a cohesive defensive effort that limits explosive plays and forces turnovers.

Tennessee’s Strengths and Challenges

On the other side of the rivalry, the Tennessee Volunteers have enjoyed a resurgence under head coach Josh Heupel. Known for his high-octane offense, Heupel has transformed Tennessee into one of the most dynamic teams in the SEC. Quarterback Joe Milton III, with his cannon-like arm, headlines an explosive attack that includes a talented corps of receivers and a formidable rushing game.

Defensively, the Volunteers have made significant strides, particularly in their front seven. Their ability to pressure opposing quarterbacks and control the line of scrimmage has been a key factor in their success this season.

However, Tennessee is not without vulnerabilities. Inconsistencies in their secondary and occasional lapses in discipline have left them exposed in certain games. For Vanderbilt to capitalize, they must exploit these weaknesses through a balanced offensive attack and efficient execution.

Keys to Victory for Vanderbilt

Win the Turnover Battle: Turnovers often decide the outcome of rivalry games. Vanderbilt’s defense must find ways to create takeaways, whether through interceptions, forced fumbles, or special teams play. On the flip side, the offense needs to prioritize ball security to avoid giving Tennessee extra opportunities.
Control the Clock: One way to neutralize Tennessee’s high-powered offense is by keeping them off the field. Vanderbilt’s running game, anchored by backs like Patrick Smith and Sedrick Alexander, will need to step up. Sustaining long drives and dominating time of possession can tilt the game in the Commodores’ favor.
Disrupt Joe Milton: Tennessee’s success hinges largely on the performance of Joe Milton III. Vanderbilt’s defensive line and linebackers must generate consistent pressure to disrupt Milton’s rhythm. Forcing him into hurried throws or sacks could swing momentum in Vanderbilt’s direction.
Special Teams Excellence: In tightly contested games, special teams often play a pivotal role. Whether it’s nailing field goals, pinning Tennessee deep with precise punts, or breaking free on kick returns, Vanderbilt’s special teams unit must be a difference-maker.

The Intangible Factors

Rivalry games are as much about emotion and psychology as they are about X’s and O’s. Vanderbilt’s players and coaching staff must embrace the magnitude of the moment without succumbing to the pressure. A confident, aggressive approach—coupled with the support of a passionate fan base—can create an atmosphere conducive to an upset.

Additionally, the Commodores must believe in their ability to defy expectations. Despite their underdog status, they have a history of proving doubters wrong. As they prepare to face Tennessee, that belief could be their most valuable asset.

Looking Ahead

The stakes are high for both programs. For Tennessee, a win solidifies their standing as one of the SEC’s top teams and bolsters their postseason aspirations. For Vanderbilt, a victory would not only serve as a statement of progress under Clark Lea but also reignite the pride and passion of their fan base.

As the Commodores and Volunteers take the field, the weight of history will be palpable. Vanderbilt’s hope lies in the notion that history has a way of repeating itself—and that this year’s team can etch its name alongside the great upsets of the past.

In the end, the “Battle for Tennessee” is more than just a football game. It’s a celebration of tradition, resilience, and the unyielding spirit of competition. For the Vanderbilt Commodores, it’s an opportunity to remind everyone that underdogs can, and often do, rise to the occasion.