The quarterback battle at the University of Alabama is one of the most closely watched position competitions in college football this offseason. With the departure of Bryce Young, the 2021 Heisman Trophy winner and first overall pick in the 2023 NFL Draft, the Crimson Tide must find a new leader under center. Athlon Sports and Lindy’s, two of the most respected preseason college football publications, have weighed in on who they believe will emerge as Alabama’s starting quarterback in 2023.
Alabama head coach Nick Saban has a history of making the right choice in quarterback battles, from Jalen Hurts to Tua Tagovailoa, and later Mac Jones and Bryce Young. This year, the competition is primarily between three candidates: Jalen Milroe, Ty Simpson, and Notre Dame transfer Tyler Buchner. Each brings a unique skill set to the table, and the decision will shape the Tide’s offensive identity this season.
Jalen Milroe: The Dual-Threat Option
Milroe, a redshirt sophomore, saw limited action last season as Young’s backup. His most notable performance came in relief against Texas A&M, where he showcased his rushing ability, tallying 81 yards on the ground. Athlon Sports has noted Milroe’s athleticism as a major factor in his favor, particularly in new offensive coordinator Tommy Rees’ system, which could incorporate more quarterback runs. Milroe’s arm strength is solid, but his accuracy and decision-making have been questioned. If he can improve in those areas, his mobility could give him the edge in the competition.
Lindy’s, however, has expressed some skepticism about Milroe’s consistency as a passer. While his physical tools are undeniable, his performance in spring practices was reportedly uneven. If Alabama wants to maintain its high-powered passing attack, Milroe will need to prove he can deliver from the pocket with the same efficiency as Young or Jones.
Ty Simpson: The High-Upside Prospect
Simpson, a redshirt freshman, was a five-star recruit in the 2022 class and is viewed by many as the future of Alabama’s quarterback position. Lindy’s has highlighted Simpson’s polished mechanics and football IQ as key strengths. Unlike Milroe, Simpson is more of a pure passer, though he has enough mobility to extend plays when needed. His ability to process defenses quickly and deliver accurate throws has drawn comparisons to previous Alabama greats.
Athlon Sports has pointed out that Simpson’s lack of game experience could work against him. While he has impressed in practice settings, the pressure of leading Alabama in a high-stakes SEC environment is a different challenge. If Simpson can demonstrate poise and command of the offense in fall camp, he could very well win the job.
Tyler Buchner: The Wild Card
The most intriguing name in the competition is Tyler Buchner, who followed Tommy Rees from Notre Dame to Alabama after entering the transfer portal. Buchner has starting experience, having played for the Fighting Irish in 2022 before an injury cut his season short. Lindy’s has noted that Buchner’s familiarity with Rees’ system could give him a significant advantage, as he already knows the terminology and play-calling tendencies.
Athlon Sports, however, has raised concerns about Buchner’s turnover issues. In his limited starts at Notre Dame, he struggled with interceptions and inconsistent accuracy. If he can clean up those mistakes, his dual-threat ability and prior relationship with Rees could make him a serious contender.
Who Do Athlon Sports and Lindy’s Think Will Win the Job?
Both publications acknowledge that this is one of the most unpredictable quarterback battles in recent Alabama history. Athlon Sports leans slightly toward Ty Simpson, citing his high ceiling and potential to grow into the role as the season progresses. They believe that while Milroe and Buchner offer more immediate mobility, Simpson’s passing ability aligns best with Alabama’s offensive philosophy under Saban.
Lindy’s, on the other hand, has suggested that Jalen Milroe might have the inside track due to his experience in the system and his dynamic running ability. With Rees potentially incorporating more quarterback-designed runs, Milroe’s skill set could be the best fit. However, Lindy’s also cautions that if Milroe doesn’t show marked improvement as a passer, Simpson could overtake him by midseason.
As for Buchner, both publications see him as a dark horse. If neither Milroe nor Simpson separates themselves, Buchner’s experience and familiarity with Rees could make him a viable option, especially early in the season.
Final Thoughts
Alabama’s quarterback battle will likely continue into fall camp, and Saban may not name a starter until just before the season opener against Middle Tennessee. Athlon Sports and Lindy’s both agree that while the competition is tight, the decision will come down to which quarterback can best balance playmaking ability with ball security and leadership.
For now, the edge seems to be with Ty Simpson according to Athlon Sports, while Lindy’s gives a slight nod to Jalen Milroe. Regardless of who wins the job, the pressure will be immense, as Alabama’s championship aspirations rest heavily on the shoulders of its next quarterback. One thing is certain: whoever emerges will have the talent around them to succeed—it’s just a matter of who can seize the opportunity.
