Reaction to Texas men’s basketball making NCAA Tournament: ‘The system is broke’

The inclusion of the Texas Longhorns in the 2025 NCAA Men’s Basketball Tournament has ignited widespread debate, with critics arguing that the selection process is fundamentally flawed. Despite a 19-15 overall record and a 6-12 conference record, Texas secured an at-large bid, raising questions about the criteria used by the NCAA Selection Committee.

Texas Longhorns’ Controversial Selection

Texas endured more losses than any other at-large selection in the tournament but is part of an SEC Conference that sent a record 14 teams to the NCAA Tournament. That rugged schedule, as well as a NET rating of 39, helped the Longhorns overcome a 6-12 conference record, which tied for 13th in the SEC.

Criticism from West Virginia Officials

The exclusion of teams like West Virginia University (WVU) has further fueled criticism of the selection process. West Virginia Governor Patrick Morrisey labeled the process as “corrupt” and called for an investigation into potential conflicts of interest, particularly highlighting the role of North Carolina’s Athletic Director, Bubba Cunningham, who chaired the selection committee.

Inconsistencies and Lack of Transparency

Critics argue that the selection process lacks transparency and consistency. For instance, ESPN analyst Seth Greenberg criticized the committee’s justifications as “weak,” highlighting the need for clearer criteria.

Debunking Common Myths

The NCAA has attempted to address these criticisms by debunking common myths about the selection process. They emphasize that the NET ranking is not the sole factor and that conference affiliation does not play a role in selection. However, these clarifications have done little to quell the controversy surrounding this year’s selections.

Calls for Reform

The ongoing debates underscore the need for a more transparent and consistent selection process. Implementing clear guidelines and reducing potential conflicts of interest are essential steps toward restoring faith in the system.