Due to injury concerns, the Miami Dolphins must make a crucial decision regarding Tua Tagovailoa’s future as they target Tyler Shough of Louisville in the NFL Draft.

by

Due to injury concerns, the Miami Dolphins must make a crucial decision regarding Tua Tagovailoa’s future as they target Tyler Shough of Louisville in the NFL Draft.

The Miami Dolphins are at a critical juncture in their franchise’s future. With starting quarterback Tua Tagovailoa’s ongoing injury concerns, the organization is evaluating its long-term strategy at the position. Reports indicate that the Dolphins are considering drafting Louisville’s Tyler Shough in the upcoming 2025 NFL Draft as insurance or a potential successor. This decision could shape the team’s trajectory for years to come.

Tua Tagovailoa: A Talented But Injury-Prone Quarterback

Tua Tagovailoa has been the face of the Dolphins’ offense since being drafted fifth overall in the 2020 NFL Draft. Despite showing flashes of brilliance, including an impressive 2023 season where he led the Dolphins to the playoffs, his career has been marred by injuries.

Tagovailoa’s college career ended with a severe hip injury, and his professional career has been plagued by multiple concussions, rib fractures, and other physical setbacks. His durability has become a growing concern for the Dolphins’ front office, coaching staff, and fanbase.

In the 2024 season, he suffered his third documented concussion, which sidelined him for multiple weeks. Additionally, a lingering hip issue raised further questions about his long-term health. While the Dolphins have publicly supported Tua, there is a growing consensus that they need a reliable contingency plan.

Evaluating Tyler Shough: The Potential Successor

Louisville quarterback Tyler Shough has emerged as a potential draft target for the Dolphins. At 6-foot-5 and 225 pounds, he possesses the prototypical size for an NFL quarterback. His arm strength, mobility, and play-action proficiency make him an intriguing option for a team looking to develop a young quarterback.

Shough’s college career has been unconventional. He began at Oregon before transferring to Texas Tech and later Louisville. Despite these moves, he demonstrated resilience and adaptability, two qualities that could benefit him in the NFL.

During the 2024 season, Shough completed 62.7% of his passes for 3,195 yards, 23 touchdowns, and six interceptions. His ability to push the ball downfield and operate within a structured offensive system has caught the attention of NFL scouts.

The Case for Drafting Shough

  1. Insurance Against Tua’s Injuries
    • Given Tagovailoa’s history, the Dolphins must prepare for a scenario where he misses extended time. Drafting Shough would provide them with a young, capable backup who could develop into a starter if needed.
  2. Long-Term Development
    • Even if Tua remains healthy, adding Shough could be a strategic move for the future. The NFL is a league where quarterback depth is crucial, and having a developmental player behind Tua could be beneficial.
  3. Scheme Fit
    • Miami’s offensive system, designed by head coach Mike McDaniel, emphasizes quick decision-making, mobility, and accuracy. Shough’s skill set aligns well with these principles, making him a strong fit for the team’s philosophy.
  4. Financial Flexibility
    • Tua Tagovailoa is approaching the end of his rookie contract. If the Dolphins choose not to extend him due to injury concerns, drafting Shough would provide a cost-effective solution at quarterback.

Counterarguments Against Drafting Shough

  1. Defensive Needs
    • The Dolphins have other pressing needs, particularly on defense. Investing a high draft pick on a quarterback instead of bolstering the pass rush or secondary could be a questionable decision.
  2. Tua’s Performance When Healthy
    • Despite his injuries, Tua has played at an elite level when available. If the organization believes in his ability to stay healthy, using draft capital on a backup quarterback may not be the best move.
  3. Shough’s Injury History
    • While Shough has shown promise, he has also dealt with injuries throughout his college career. Drafting an injury-prone quarterback to back up another injury-prone quarterback could be a risky proposition.

Strategic Implications for the Dolphins

If the Dolphins decide to draft Tyler Shough, it would signal a clear shift in their approach to the quarterback position. It could mean they are preparing for life beyond Tua or simply ensuring they have a viable backup plan.

Alternatively, if they pass on Shough, it would demonstrate their confidence in Tua’s ability to lead the team despite the injury risks.

The Miami Dolphins are at a crossroads regarding Tua Tagovailoa’s future. While he has proven to be a dynamic playmaker when healthy, his durability remains a major concern. The potential selection of Tyler Shough in the 2025 NFL Draft could provide the Dolphins with a much-needed safety net.

As the draft approaches, Miami’s decision will be one of the most scrutinized storylines in the league. Will they solidify their commitment to Tua, or will they take a step toward a new era with Shough? Only time will tell.

Leave a Comment